I am visiting my parents in Calcutta, the city in which I grew up. Once again, like every time I come back here, I am filled with a sense of loss, a sense of longing for what can never be had.

I have chosen the city of New York. It has embraced me. It has its flaws, but so do I. We have accepted each other for better or worse, and I would rather live there than anywhere else in the world.

I harbor a hundred resentments against Calcutta. I have hashed and re-hashed its million faults. But it is the city that knew me in my youth. It heard peals of my childish laughter, and watched the rivulets of my girlish tears. It was there when my hopes and dreams were untarnished by practicality, when I believed in knights on white horses and rainbows at the end of the road, when I sang romantic songs from old Hindi films in public. I have scraped my knees and scraped my heart on its streets. It accompanied me on so many adventures and misadventures as I took my first unsteady steps on the road to adulthood. It stood witness to my first kiss, and my first broken promise. And I have known it. The sights, the scents, the sounds — I never think of them when I am away, but every time I’m here again, they rush back like the familiar words to a forgotten song. The footpaths, the theaters, the bus stops, the parks — every corner is awash in the chatter of my school friends. The city holds a magic for me that I cannot shake off even if I try.

When I lived in Calcutta, I had scant appreciation for all this. I lived life with zest, but I always longed for more. I would never have admitted it to myself at the time, but I was not ready to grow up and settle down. I needed to spread my wings and fly out into the world. It indisputedly loved me, and I rejected it without a second thought. I didn’t know enough to value that love. I didn’t know enough to recognize how rare and precious true love is. My choices would not have changed, but I should have known what I was trading in.

The bitch of it is that even if I go back, I can never go back. That time and place is lost forever, and longing can do nothing more than twist my heart. I can visit, but I know, and the city knows, that I am a mere visitor.

Rabindranath Tagore — Bengal’s pre-eminent author, dramatist, poet and song-writer — wrote a song that translates roughly as this:

Who have you left behind, my heart?
You found no peace, a lifetime passed.
My heart, who have you left behind?

You long forgot the path you took,
How can you ever even look
Down the path you left behind?

(You can listen to a beautiful rendition of this song here. )

We know we can’t go back. So why do we indulge in looking back with that mixture of sadness and pleasure called nostalgia? Psychological authorities tell us that living in the present is best for mental health. But in reality, how does one divide one’s mind into day-tight compartments? ¬†Practice, they say, practice. Easier said than done. Perhaps there should be AA-like support groups for those trying to cure themselves of nostalgia. Perhaps “Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind” was not such a bad idea after all. I don’t actually advocate forgetting. I do advocate detachment from memories. And yet, and yet…

This entry was posted in Mental Health and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Nostalgia

  1. swamimalathi says:

    Great writing. Captures very well the longing for people, places and identities that we valued and relished, that we have left behind and moved beyond, and know we can never go back to.

    I think nostalgia and longing is fine, as long as we have the detachment you mention – a practical side that keeps us aware that choices have to be made in life, and that “we can’t go home again”. Even if we do, it is a new place we used to know, not the same place.

    I feel it particularly strongly for all the great people I have known but lost touch with. I still feel good about them, and with modern technology it is easy to get in touch with them again, but staying in touch – that’s a different matter.

    Thanks for a great piece.


    Liked by 1 person

  2. kathaykathay says:

    Very nicely put. The imagery you conjure is absolutely brilliant, and I can’t help diving into the depths of nostalgia myself.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. A lovely and well written post:)


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s